[Pdx-pm] Lisp class
jeff at vpservices.com
Sun May 1 11:10:44 PDT 2005
Ben Kirkpatrick wrote:
>>Really? can you name some of these studies which say that this ability
>>is progressively degenerative with age beyond a fairly young cut-off for
>>early childhood language acquisition?
>In the studies I've seen, a child learning a language has a better chance
>of speaking it with the same accent as a native. An adult would have to
>spend a lot of time with a therapist to get the details correct.
Yes, I've seen studies to that effect. They are about pronunciation, not
understanding and therefore are completely irrelevant to a discussion of
programming languages. That is, unless you've noticed a difference in
programming ability between those who pronounce "lib" as in "liberty"
rather than as "library" and "bin" as in "trash bin" rather than as in
>So it really means that as you age you are less likely to perfect/acquire
>a new language. But there is certainly no accounting for determination.
Yes, that's right. And "less likely" is by definition a relative term.
To make generalizations that person X is less likely to be able to learn
new programming languages because they are age Y is to ignore the many
more important factors such as motivation, interests, mental habits,
previous learning experiences, etc.
BTW, does someone have a link to where Paul Graham talks about age and
>As an aside, I seem to remember a story about a Hungarian gentleman who
>taught himself Icelandic from a single book.
Someone should go arrest the guy for violating the laws of nature :-).
More information about the Pdx-pm-list